31st APOR 2019, Taipei Taiwan September 25-27 September 2019

The Australasia & Pacific Regional Conference is comprised of Taiwan and Hong Kong from Asia and New Zealand, Australia, Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea, Vanuatu, Tonga, Samoa, Cook Islands from the Pacific and is likely to see more growth in membership.

The Australasia & Pacific Region (APOR) is one of the six regional chapters of the International Ombudsman Institute (IOI). It holds conferences every year, and this year Taiwan’s Control Yuan hosted its 31st Conference over a 3 day period.

The first day of Conference saw members providing brief reports from each jurisdiction and was represented by Taiwan, Hong Kong, Australia, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, and Cook Islands.

Figure 1 Ombudsman Tearea and Deputy Ombudsman Daniel at APOR members Business meeting
Figure 1 Ombudsman Tearea and Deputy Ombudsman Daniel at APOR members Business meeting


Seminar 1: Practices and Recent Development of the International Ombudsman Institute.

This session was moderated by Hsiao-hung Nancy Chen, Control Yuan, Republic of China (Taiwan), Member.

Panel speakers were Carmen Comas-Mata Mira, Secretary-General, Ibero-American Federation of Ombudsman (FIO), Head of International Affairs in the Office of the Spanish Ombudsman

Werner Amon, who was recently appointed the Secretary-General, International Ombudsman Institute (IOI) and incumbent Austrian Ombudsman

Chris Field
Chris Field

Second Vice President, International Ombudsman Institute (IOI), and incumbent Western Australia Ombudsman.

Figure 2 Ombudsman Tearea and Deputy Ombudsman at the first seminar of APOR 2019


Seminar Two: The Ombudsman and the Protection of Economically and Socially Disadvantaged People’s Human Rights

This session was moderated by Michael Dick, Chief Ombudsman from the Ombudsman Commission of Papua New Guinea.

Panel Speakers in this session were: Deborah Glass who is the Victorian Ombudsman, but also a Director of APOR

Mei-yu Wang, Member of Control Yuan, Republic of China (Taiwan)

Michael Manthorpe, Commonwealth Ombudsman, Australia

Session 3: The Multifunctional Role of the Ombudsman

This session was moderated by Phil Clarke, Queensland Ombudsman, Australia

Panel Speakers in this session were:

Peter Boshier, President of APOR, Ombudsman of New Zealand

Tzong-ho Bau Convener, International Affairs Committee, Control Yuan Member, Control Yuan, Republic of China (Taiwan)

Iitsuka Masao, Director, Administrative Counselling Office, Administrative Evaluation Bureau, MIC, Japan

Elizabeth Rynning, Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman, Sweden

Our gracious hosts also offered a tour of Taipei City through the National Palace Museum and the Lin Family Mansion and Gardens.

Figure 3Deputy Ombudsman Daniel and Ombudsman Tearea outside the Control Yuah preparing for the City Tour
Figure 3Deputy Ombudsman Daniel and Ombudsman Tearea outside the Control Yuah preparing for the City Tour
Figure 4 Chief Ombudsman Boshier (NZ) with Deputy Ombudsman Daniel looks on at the many Chinese treasures

Figure 5Waitress describes the dishes on the towers to a table of APOR conference members

Figure 5 Waitress describes the dishes on the towers to a table of APOR conference members

Figure 6Group photo outside the Lin Family Mansion & Gardens
Figure 6 Group photo outside the Lin Family Mansion & Gardens


Figure 7 Ombudsman Tearea and Deputy Ombudsman Daniel presents gift to Po-ya Chang, President, Control Yuan, Republic of China (Taiwan)
Figure 7 Ombudsman Tearea and Deputy Ombudsman Daniel presents gift to Po-ya Chang, President, Control Yuan, Republic of China (Taiwan)

Human Rights Training, Nadi, Fiji 2019

The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights – Regional Office for the Pacific (OHCHR-ROP) hosted a three day Regional Human Rights and Climate Change Conference focusing on climate justice, national human rights institutions, and migration in the context of climate change in the Pacific from 5-7 August 2019, in Nadi, Fiji

The conference amongst other things considered the negative impacts caused by climate change in the region. The Conference brought together around 50 participants including Government Officials from Pacific Island countries, representatives of civil society regional organisations, international and regional organisations and national human rights institution officials to share their knowledge and help Pacific countries explore ways to raise the visibility of climate change justice, business and human rights, migration, adaptation and resilience including specific sessions to address individual thematic human rights issues.

The three day conference included the following thematic sessions:

• Climate change in the Pacific – Resilience, adaptation and mitigation
• Introduction to Human Rights – The international Bill of Human Rights, and the International Human Rights Mechanisms
• How National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) can champion climate change
• NHRIs and Climate Justice – What roles can they play and how can we build effective partnerships
• Introduction to UN Guiding Principles and linkages with SDGs
• Business responsibility for Climate Change
• Climate induced migration – identifying the issues, developments and key themes
• Ensuring the dignity, safety, and human rights of migrants are protected in the context of climate change
• Ensuring access to justice for those affected by climate change

Of particular interest to Senior Investigation Officer Nootai was these session facilitated by Roberto Cadiz, Human Rights Commissioner of the Philippines. The office is conscious that climate change migration is an inevitability and will take this into account in its strategic direction.

Investigator Training, Nadi, Fiji 2019

On 31 July 2019 and 1 August 2019 our two senior investigators, Liz Nootai and Joyce Ingram, attended Investigator Training hosted by the New Zealand Chief Ombudsman, Peter Boshier. The training was held at the Tanoa International Hotel in Nadi, Fiji.

The main facilitators of the training were from the Office of the Commonwealth Ombudsman – Director of Operations (North), Shirley Tong, Victorian Ombudsman Office – Strategic Advisor, Amanda Wilczynski, Energy and Water Ombudsman of Western Australia – Director of Energy and Water, Marcus Claridge and NZ Office of the Ombudsman – Principal Advisor, Tracey Harlen. We also had presenters from United Nations Human Rights, United Nations Development Programme and Anti-Corruption.

The two-day training took the investigators through a live case from the assessment through to the final opinion. The techniques and advice given by the experts have already proven to be useful within our local office they have been used to on current cases.

Takeaway from this workshop
• The network of friends and Ombudsman family that our office now has within the Pacific.
• That the message to an agency is of collaboration and not to lay blame.
• Sharing experiences with other investigators – for e.g our investigative experiences in the Cook Islands are so much different to those in Papua New Guinea.

Thank you Chief Ombudsman, Peter Boshier for allowing our office to be part of this training initiative.

Ombudsman’s Training in Wellington, New Zealand 29 April to 3 May 2019

With the assistance of the Chief Ombudsman of New Zealand Judge Peter Boshier, Ombudsman Tearea was able to undergo an early week-long training in the Ombudsman’s Office in Wellington.

There were many areas or topics covered during the week-long training. He was allocated to various teachers for each topic covered. Some of the topics covered may be summarised as follows;

1. Overview of the organisational structure, organisational values and the Ombudsman’s role
2. People & Capability – Overview of the personnel management. We call it here Human Resource Management.
3. Information and technology
4. International relations and the Ombudsman organisation such as APOR and IOI .Analysis ofNew Zealand and Cook Islands Ombudsman Acts in terms of jurisdiction by Tracey Harlen. This included an overview of the New Ombudsman Bill of the Cook Islands.
5. Ombudsman Act complaint handling and best practices.
6. Jurisdiction and comparative analysis of New Zealand and Cook Islands Official Information Act
7. Overview of OPCAT – inspection of prisons and Police holding cell. Selected reports were also provided
8. Meeting and discussion with IPCA Chair Judge Colin Doherty on investigating complaints about the Police and the Cook Islands Police Act 2012.
9. Teleconference session on Disability Rights with Auckland based team. This was an overview on how disability rights work in New Zealand including training ideas, solutions and support.

Undoubtedly the expansive nature of the New Zealand Ombudsman Office with clear demarcation of different roles is very impressive. Understandably that was no comparison for our small Office here in Rarotonga. He enjoyed viewing the technology employed in the Office including Waka, Awa and their new website which at the time was still being tested. I was also impressed with the calibre of each and every staff employed in their various divisions in the Office. In addition, he was surprised by their budgetary process in that it goes direct to Parliamentary Select Committee for consideration as opposed to going through Budget Committee, Cabinet and then to Parliament in the Cook Islands.